Largest Review/Discussion Fansite for Supernatural and SPNFamily Shows! Plot/Character Analysis, Spoilers, Games, News, Gallery, Interviews, Fun!

With the show going into its final season, I started to reflect on the past fourteen years and the episodes that are still, to this day, the nearest and dearest to my heart. To me they are my comfort episodes, the ones I go to when I need a laugh or a cry or the comfort of an old friend.  I have picked my Top Six Favourites of each season, which I have to admit it was hard (going with only six?!).    

Before you read my list, make your own list of season 1 favorites! It will be fun to compare your unbiased choices (before you are unduly influenced by my memories or picks) to mine.  If you're joining Nightsky and The WFB in the #SPNSummer2019 Rewatch, viewing the TNT Supernatural Marathon, or rewatching at your own pace this hiatus, the episodes should be fresh in your mind! Save your list then, because you'll need it for a HUGE Hiatus challenge that The WFB will be sharing with you very soon! Nightsky reveals her Top 6 season 1 favorites after mine, so you'll have two WFB staff lists as a comparison (and as a hint of what's to come!)!

So without further ado, here's my list of Season One Favourites! The list is by order of appearance only, as they all are equal in their importance to me. 

1) The Pilot 

SPN 0001

The Pilot was our introduction episode.   

SPN 0029

It introduced us to John and Mary Winchester,


and to our beloved brothers Sam and Dean Winchester. 

Sam the younger, more serious and studious brother.

Dean the older , wisecracking, classic rock loving brother.    

supernatural101 001030

And of course there was the introduction to "Baby" Winchester.  Who, through out the years, we learned was not only their transportation, but their protector and, at times, their home.     

1.01 0409 Tapes

It established the MUSIC .... primarily from the 80's.  

SPN 0946

It introduced us to the Supernatural World of Urban Legends.  Starting with The Lady in White, a ghost who killed those who were unfaithful. The CGI was amazing and super creepy.  

SPN 0031

It also started us on our journey of many mysteries and questions, like who or what killed....    


 Mary and ...

SPN 1071

... Jessica, and why were they killed, and in that manner.  

1 1 01 Journal

We were then left with the question, "Where is John and why is he not getting in touch with Dean, 

and why did he leave his journal behind, when he never went anywhere without it?"  

2) Home

vlcsnap 00030

The boys go back to their family home, due to Sam's visions.   

SPN 1010

A treasure box of the Winchester's old pictures are found.  

vlcsnap 00065 

We were introduced to clairvoyant Missouri.  


This was our first little reassuring hug/squeeze  from Dean to Sam. 


Dean's emotional call to his dad.


A scared Sam asking Missouri, "What's happening to me?"     

vlcsnap 00103

The spirit of Mary comes to save her boy after first apologising to Sam. 


John also makes a surprise appearance, responding to Dean's call but he still won't speak to his boys. 

SPN 0450

As for the scary, the repairman getting his hand mulched in the disposal unit was one of those 'totally creeped out and have to look away' moments. 

3) Faith


Dean gets electrocuted and his heart is now damaged.   

SPN 0369

Sam is fully devoted to saving Dean.   

SPN 0742

The amazing montage with Blue Oyster Cult's "Don't Fear The Reaper".   

SPN 1441

Layla - how brave she was. "I guess if you're gonna have faith, you can't just have it when the miracles happen." 


The makeup for the Reaper was pretty 'creepy'!


4) Nightmare


This was my first watched episode. I was absolutely blown away and immediately hooked.

I loved the comedic moments, especially when Sam and Dean posed as priests.


I loved the brother's relationship. The concern Dean had for his brother Sam ....    

SPN 0465

 ...when Sam had his visions.  

SPN 0499

The build up of suspense, knowing that the window was coming down.   

SPN 1140

The shock of seeing Dean getting shot and killed. Luckily it was only a vision. However, I to give kudos to the CGI Crew.  

SPN 1167

The acting was amazing by all. I found myself very sympathetic to Max, even though I couldn't condone his use of his abilities. Once again, the CGI crew was amazing with the floating gun...

SPN 0788

The flying knife....

SPN 0969

and the spinning letter opener. 

5)Something Wicked

SPN 0479

The flashback of the brothers when they were young. Seeing Dean caring for Sam.  

SPN 0364

Seeing John as a father in those early days.  Some may have found him harsh, but after seeing his wife slashed and burning to death on their infant son's bedroom ceiling, I could understand his over protection and strict parenting....and his obsession for revenge.   

SPN 1233

The Striga monster that sucked out its young victim's life essence.   


Sam learning more about what happened years ago from Dean.    

SPN 1083 1

I really like the character Michael. He was a bit of a smart-ass but he truly loved and cared about his younger brother.  


SPN 0318

The motel room was priceless ....    

SPN 0317

.... including the brothers' reactions.  


Meeting Sarah, and Sam's first attempt at a relationship after Jessica.   

SPN 0469

The brothers scaling the fence.  I have to admit, I got all 'Twitter-pated'  with that scene. 

SPN 0606

I loved how they both shut the car door at the same time. They would continue to show the brothers' closeness by doing various things in sync.  


The creepy painting ....  

SPN 1183

....along with the creepy spirit.  

So those are my top favourites for Season One.

As promised, here are Nightsky's Top 6 Season One Favorites, in order of preference:

1.    1.19 "Provenance"
2.    1.09 "Home"
3.    1.22 "Devil's Trap"
4.    1.16 "Shadow"
5.    1.01 "Pilot"
6.    1.12 "Faith"

Now it's your turn!  Which episodes make your top 6? What surprised you, either by inclusion or exclusion, from my or Nightsky's lists? Make your lists now, if you didn't before you read our favorites. You're going to need them later for WFB's Ultimate Hiatus Challenge!

Having fun comparing favorites? Keep going with Karen and Nightsky's Top 6 Favorite Season 2 Episodes

Please share your thoughts below! 

See The WFB's other Top 10 Lists! There are so many ways to enjoy Supernatural!