The concept is simple. Below is the list of the 23 episodes of “Supernatural” season eleven. In five minutes (give or take a couple), rank the episodes the way you see if from best to worst. Don’t take too much time to think about it, go with your gut feel. That’s the whole point of this exercise, to get the initial reaction. Overthinking just skews results!
Below are the episodes in order from season 11. Aren’t sure which ones are which? Just go to our handy/dandy Supernatural Season Eleven Episode Guide for the descriptions of each episode before you begin.
Out of the Darkness, Into the Fire
Form and Void
The Bad Seed
Baby
Thin Lizzie
Our Little World
Plush
Just My Imagination
O’Brother Where Art Thou?
The Devil in the Details
Into the Mystic
Don’t You Forget About Me
Love Hurts
The Vessel
Beyond the Mat
Safe House
Red Meat
Hell’s Angel
The Chitters
Don’t Call Me Shurley
All in the Family
We Happy Few
Alpha and Omega
I ranked the episodes, but it was a bit harder this year. All in all, this took me about 6.5 minutes. I knew my best and I knew my worst, but the rest didn’t come off so well. This is also the first year ever where the season ending episodes ranked the lowest for me. My worst score ever. Probably because a lot of the middle episodes were really the same in terms of ranking to me. Here is my episode ranking from best to worst:
Baby
Don’t Call Me Shurley
Safe House
The Vessel
Form and Void
Red Meat
Just My Imagination
Our Little World
Thin Lizzie
Into the Mystic
Plush
The Devil in the Details
Out of the Darkness, Into the Fire
Beyond the Mat
Hell’s Angel
The Bad Seed
Don’t You Forget About Me
Love Hurts
All in The Family
Alpha and Omega
O’Brother Where Art Thou?
The Chitters
We Happy Few
Okay, your turn! Share your rankings in the comments below. I love reading the results of these episode rankings every year because they are always so different, yet there tends to be a majority rule on some of them, especially best and worst. It definitely demonstrates how the season gone by impacted fans on such a different level. Its darn right scientific!
So for the sake of science I urge you to go ahead, rank ‘em in five minutes!
Out of the Darkness, Into the Fire
Form and Void
The Bad Seed
Baby
Thin Lizzie
Our Little World
Plush
Just My Imagination
O’Brother Where Art Thou?
The Devil in the Details
Into the Mystic
Don’t You Forget About Me
Love Hurts
The Vessel
Beyond the Mat
Safe House
Red Meat
Hell’s Angel
The Chitters
Don’t Call Me Shurley
All in the Family
We Happy Few
Alpha and Omega
I ranked the episodes, but it was a bit harder this year. All in all, this took me about 6.5 minutes. I knew my best and I knew my worst, but the rest didn’t come off so well. This is also the first year ever where the season ending episodes ranked the lowest for me. My worst score ever. Probably because a lot of the middle episodes were really the same in terms of ranking to me. Here is my episode ranking from best to worst:
Baby
Don’t Call Me Shurley
Safe House
The Vessel
Form and Void
Red Meat
Just My Imagination
Our Little World
Thin Lizzie
Into the Mystic
Plush
The Devil in the Details
Out of the Darkness, Into the Fire
Beyond the Mat
Hell’s Angel
The Bad Seed
Don’t You Forget About Me
Love Hurts
All in The Family
Alpha and Omega
O’Brother Where Art Thou?
The Chitters
We Happy Few
Okay, your turn! Share your rankings in the comments below. I love reading the results of these episode rankings every year because they are always so different, yet there tends to be a majority rule on some of them, especially best and worst. It definitely demonstrates how the season gone by impacted fans on such a different level. Its darn right scientific!
So for the sake of science I urge you to go ahead, rank ‘em in five minutes!
